Sometimes the only way to move forward is to let go of the past. As library authors, we are particularly cognizant that the environments we support has a direct impact on the environments you, as developers, support. After all, turning away a visitor at the door means fewer visitors and lost revenue/mindshare.

To date, each cujoJS project independently chooses which environments it actively tests against. This makes it harder to determine the supported environments when using multiple cujoJS projects. We'd like to fix that. Before making any changes we be clear about our plans, and provide an opportunity for feedback.

Proposed policy

Here's what we intend to actively support across all of the cujoJS projects:

  • Node.js (stable and previous stable)
  • any browser with >1% global market share*

*Environment must be available for automated testing. There are many sources of browser stats, we're currently leaning on the browser usage tables on Can I use...

Impact

If we consider the state of the browser universe right now, these are the supported environments:

  • Chrome stable
  • Firefox stable
  • Safari 6 and 5.1
  • IE 10, 9 and 8
  • iOS 6
  • Node.js 0.10 and 0.8

Automated testing

When we claim to support an environment, we actually want to prove it works. All cujoJS projects have robust test suites. In order to ensure a supported environment actually works, we leverage Travis CI and Sauce Labs to run the test suite in every supported environment. Unfortunately, not every browser known to man is available within Sauce Labs. Even if a browser has sufficient market share, if we can't automate our test suite to ensure it works, we can't officially support it. At the moment the Android browser has sufficient marketshare, but is not well supported within Sauce Labs.

Just because an environment isn't supported, doesn't mean it won't work. It simply means that we don't test within that particular environment. If you find bugs in an unsupported environment, please continue to report the issue. We will accept pull requests that fix issues in unsupported environments as long as it doesn't break a supported environment or adversely affect the code base. We just can't guarantee that the environment will not break again in the future; because of course, there are no automated tests.

The bleeding edge

Supporting an environment doesn't mean that every feature will work natively within that environment. For example, many projects already assume an ES5 environment, or a polyfilled ES5-esque environment; cujojs/poly and kriskowal/es5-shim work well. We refuse to be handcuffed to the lowest common denominator. If a feature within a project requires functionality that is not available in all supported environments it will be supplementary and not essential, moreover it will be documented as such. Whenever possible, a less feature rich work around will also be available.

Future releases

Of course, we won't drop support for a browser in a point release. When we do drop a browser, it will be clearly listed in the change log. Individual projects may support additional environments; each project will clearly list the supported environments. As newer versions of each environment are released, we will attempt to support the new environment quickly in a point release. We are attempting to create a common floor, not a celling.

Too painful?

If this change will make your life as an application developer painful, now is your opportunity to yell.